Skip to main content
Nicos Pizza logo top - HomepageNicos Pizza logo scroll - Homepage
  • (414)-316-9557
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Franchise Opportunities
  • Reserve
  • Facebook page
  • Google page
Nicos Pizza logo top - HomepageNicos Pizza logo scroll - Homepage
  • Facebook page
  • Google page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Order
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs
  • Franchise Opportunities
  • Reserve

Our Menu

  • Menu

Appetizers

Nico's Signature Garlic Bread
$8.95

Fresh baked bread from Peter Sciortino Bakery, fresh garlic, and fresh basil • Add Cheese +$3.00

Basket O' Fries
$6.95

Thin - cut French fries deep - fried golden brown with our special house seasoning.

Nico's Powerhouse Buffalo Thighs
$14.50

Big hunks of boneless skinless chicken thigh meat, tender and juicy, with our house - made buffalo sauce. Served with Ranch or Blue Cheese dressing • Add Celery +$1.00

Fresh Mozzarella Medallions Caprese Style
$14.75

Three thick slices of our fresh mozzarella, hand - breaded, fried, and garnished with fresh basil, tomato, and balsamic glaze.

The Mammoth Portobello Mushroom
$17.50

A whole large Portobello mushroom, lightly seasoned and dipped in our own tempura - style batter. Fried and served over a pool of our house marinara.

Sandwiches, Burgers, and More

Nico's Almost Famous Pizza Burger
$14.75

Hand - molded fresh Italian sausage patty charbroiled, served on a Peter Sciortino Bakery bun, with melted mozzarella - Asiago cheese, our house pizza sauce, green bell pepper, and onion. Served with fries.

The Classic Burger
$14.95

1/2 pound choice Black Angus ground chuck charbroiled burger, with lettuce, tomato, and onions. Served with fries • Add choice of available cheeses +$1.00

Nico's Italian Beef Sandwich
$14.95

Generous portion of thinly sliced Italian beef, green peppers, red onion, and mozzarella - Asiago cheese. Served with fries and au jus.

The Almighty Caesar
$13.50

Romaine, red onion, croutons, Parmesan cheese, and house Caesar dressing • Add Grilled Chicken +$5.00

Uncle Vinny's Italian Sausage
$17.50

Uncle Vinny's house recipe: 1/2 pound mild Italian sausage, with sautéed bell peppers, Grande's mozzarella - Asiago cheese, onions, pepperoncinis, and Nico's marinara on a fresh roll. Served with fries.

Garden Basil Chicken Sandwich
$15.50

Grilled chicken breast, fresh mozzarella, garlic sautéed mushrooms and onions, fresh basil pesto, and balsamic vinegar glaze on a fresh toasted roll. Served with fries or house vegetable.

The Garden Salad
$13.50

Spring greens, boutique medley tomatoes, green peppers, fresh Portobello mushrooms, red onion, house-made croutons, and Parmesan-Romano cheese. Choice of available dressings • Add Chicken +$5.00

Nico's Ultimate Mushroom and Swiss Burger
$17.50

1/2 pound choice Black Angus beef, charbroiled. Giant fresh Portobello mushroom cap, sautéed in butter, fresh garlic, white wine, and seasonings, Swiss cheese, all on a Peter Sciortino Bakery bun. Served with fries.

Entrées

Comastro's Pasta
$25.50

Tender fettuccini and sliced handmade Italian sausage in Nico's original Comastro's pink sauce made from cream, Sicilian gravy, garlic, spices, Parmesan and Romano cheeses, white wine, and finished off with a bit of vodka. Served with garlic bread and mini - Caprese stick.

Nico's Five Cheese Lasagna
$25.50

Choice Angus ground beef, house pork, plum tomatoes, red onion, green peppers, fresh garlic, basil, white wine, and Nico's own special spices create Nico's meat sauce, with mozzarella, Asiago, ricotta, Parmesan, and Romano cheeses. Served with garlic bread and mini - Caprese on a stick.

Portobello Buca
$26.50

Sliced Portobello sautéed in butter, fresh garlic, white wine, special seasonings, and a touch of Black Sambuca served over fettuccini. Topped with a made - to - order Sicilian meatball. Served with garlic bread and Caprese on a stick.

Sicilian Sausage and Garden Pasta
$25.50

Sliced house hot Sicilian sausage, fire - roasted tomatoes, red onion, green peppers, sautéed in butter, fresh garlic, white wine, and a touch of Absolut Peppar vodka. Served with garlic bread and mini - Caprese on a stick.

Chef's Special - Sicilian Flats

Hand pressed oval shaped crust made with three different flours, crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. Oval shaped and generously topped with our fresh ingredients. Ask your server for availability

Friday Fish Fry

3 pieces of hand battered fish with our own Italian seasoning, fries, creamy coleslaw, rye bread. Served with tartar sauce.

Pizza

The Classic

12' $20.50 | 14' $24.50 • Nico's sauce, mozzarella - Asiago blend, Nico's sausage, fresh mushrooms, and red onions.

The Catania

12' $20.50 | 14' $24.50 • Nico's sauce, fresh mozzarella, fresh ricotta, sliced poblano pepper rings, boutique medley grape tomatoes, and fresh basil.

Build Your Own

12' $18.00 | 14' $21.00 • Start with mozzarella - Asiago blend • Vegetable toppings +$2.00: green bell peppers, fresh mushrooms, red onion, pickled jalapeño, pickled pepperoncini, black olives, and minced garlic • Meat toppings +$3.00: sausage and pepperoni • Add Extra Vegetable Toppings +$2.00

The Magnificent Portobello and Sausage

12' $20.50 | 14' $24.50 • Nico's sauce, fresh mozzarella, sausage, sliced giant Portobello mushroom caps, and fresh basil.

The Tasty Firecracker

12' $20.50 | 14' $23.50 • Nico's sauce blended with Texas Pete's hot sauce, mozzarella - Asiago blend, jumbo sliced pepperoni, red onion rings, and pickled jalapeños.

The Sharp Dressed Man

12' $21.50 | 14' $25.50 • Nico's sauce, mozzarella - Asiago blend, jumbo pepperoni slices, Nico's sausage, red onion rings, and strips of sharp cheddar.

The Portnoy

12' $18.00 | 14' $21.00 • Just a cheese pizza with no flop, a little char, and a triangle cut.

Dessert

Pistachio Cheesecake
$10.00

Light and delicious. Served with glaze and crushed pistachios.

Tiramisu
$10.00

An Italian favorite.

Daily Lunch Specials

11:00 AM - 2:00 PM

The Mighty Slice
$8.50

Cut in triangles off a Mighty 18' pizza. Your choice of cheese, sausage, or pepperoni, or Classic (cheese, sausage, mushroom, onions) • Double Mighty Slice (2 slices) $14.50

Pizza Burger & Fries
$11.00
1/3 Pound Hamburger & Fries
$11.00
Spaghetti & Garlic Bread
$11.00
Garden Salad w/Grilled Chicken
$11.00
Super Slice & Side Salad
$11.00
Nico's Ultimate Pizza Bread
$11.00

Up to 3 toppings.

Sides

Extra Dressings
$1.60
Nico's Pizza Sauce
$2.00
House Marinara
$2.00
House Vegetables
$5.50

Location

Nicos Pizza
9638 West National Avenue
West Allis, WI
53227
Get Directions

Hours

KITCHEN HOURS

Monday – Saturday: 11 AM – 9 PM
Sunday: 11 AM – 8:30 PM

BAR HOURS

Open Daily at 11 AM
Open Late – Hours Vary Based on Events and Business

Please call for specific dates and hours.

Find us on...

Facebook pageGoogle page

Contact us

Call us at (414)-316-9557

  • Order
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs